The opinions expressed in The Lawrentian are those of the students, faculty and community members who wrote them. The Lawrentian does not endorse any opinions piece except for the staff editorial, which represents a majority of the editorial board. The Lawrentian welcomes everyone to submit their own opinions. For the full editorial policy and parameters for submitting articles, please refer to the About section.
As the spooky season comes to an end each year, a beloved debate reignites among fans of Tim Burton’s 1993 cult classic, “The Nightmare Before Christmas.” Is it a Halloween movie or a Christmas film? This question sparks passionate discussions, with enthusiasts on both sides presenting compelling arguments.
Before we break down this debate, here is brief refresher for those who may need one. “The Nightmare Before Christmas” follows Jack Skellington, the Pumpkin King of Halloween Town, who feels trapped in the monotony of his annual Halloween festivities. Celebrated by the town’s residents — especially the zealous Mayor — Jack enjoys acclaim for his frightening talents. Yet beneath the surface, he struggles with a profound sense of purposelessness, yearning for something more fulfilling.
Jack’s life takes a dramatic turn when he stumbles upon Christmas Town, a vibrant realm filled with joy, hope and dazzling lights. The enchanting sights and sounds exhilarate him, reigniting his passion for something new and magical. Eager to bring a taste of Christmas to Halloween Town, he enthusiastically decides to take on the role of Santa Claus, blissfully unaware of the chaos that will ensue. However, Jack’s ambitious plan is shadowed by visions from Sally, a clever but misunderstood ragdoll created by the reclusive Dr. Finkelstein. Sally, who admires Jack and longs for his acknowledgment, foresees the disastrous consequences of his well-intentioned efforts. Torn between her affection for Jack and her desire to protect the spirit of Christmas, she faces the daunting challenge of saving him from his misguided ambitions, knowing that his enthusiasm might lead to unforeseen disasters.
While many argue that it is a Christmas movie solely because of its title and the fact that it culminates on Christmas Day, I am here to set the record straight: “The Nightmare Before Christmas” is fundamentally a Halloween movie. Here’s why: although part of the film focuses on Jack’s attempt to take over Christmas, the core narrative revolves around his quest for purpose. In the pantheon of Christmas films, themes of joy and hope dominate; in contrast, this film is steeped in spooky creatures, villainy and dark irony.
At its heart, the movie captures Jack’s journey of self-discovery. By the end, he learns that his true fulfillment comes not from usurping Christmas, but from recognizing those who have supported him all along — most notably, Sally. Their relationship evolves into a haunting love story, revealing that Sally — whom he initially overlooks in his pursuit of purpose — has been there for him every step of the way. She supports him throughout the film, from gifting him a basket of treats while he conducts science experiments, to warning him of the doom that could arise from his plans for Christmas, to sewing his Santa Claus outfit despite her misgivings. Ultimately, she becomes the savior of both Christmas and Jack, rescuing Santa from the clutches of the wicked Oogie Boogie and preventing Jack from spiraling into disaster.
“The Nightmare Before Christmas” resonates with the themes of Halloween: it explores the tension between familiarity and the unknown, the quest for identity and the realization that true connection lies in recognizing and valuing those we often overlook. So, as the spooky season comes to an end, I stand firm in my belief that this enchanting tale is, at its core, a celebration of Halloween — a mesmerizing exploration of darkness, purpose and, ultimately, love.
In the end, Jack Skellington comes to a profound realization: his true talent and purpose lies in embracing his role as the Pumpkin King of Halloween. Throughout his journey, he has ventured away from what made him special, briefly enticed by the allure of Christmas and the fantasies it promised. However, it is Sally who becomes the catalyst for his awakening, as she has been his loyal friend and unsung supporter all along. With her by his side, he envisions a new kind of partnership — one that defines their roles not just in Halloween Town, but in their lives together.
“The Nightmare Before Christmas” is undeniably a Halloween movie, and Jack Skellington’s journey underscores this assertion. As the embodiment of Halloween, Jack feels trapped in his role as a mere figurehead of fright. He is celebrated for his terrifying talents, yet is seen only as the haunting specter of Halloween Town. The townsfolk admire him but understand him only superficially, failing to recognize the depth of his true identity and desires. This reflection reveals not just the struggles of a Halloween icon, but also the broader themes that resonate with the essence of Halloween.
Sally is the key figure who sees Jack for who he truly is — a soul with dreams, insecurities and yearnings. It is through her eyes that he begins to understand the importance of individuality and the richness of connection. Their bond illustrates that Halloween is not solely about scares and spooks; it is about the deeper connections that can be forged in the shadows. Jack recognizes that it was Sally’s unwavering support — her quiet yet powerful presence — that had filled the void he felt throughout his reign as Pumpkin King. They are “simply meant to be,” one could say: two souls intertwined in their mutual longing for connection. In their relationship, love and companionship become the true spirit of Halloween. Their shared experience breathes new life into Halloween Town, suggesting that the holiday can encompass more than just fright; it can be a celebration of unity and understanding.
Jack’s transformation is pivotal in cementing the film’s Halloween identity. His acceptance of who he is signifies a return to the core values of Halloween — a celebration of individuality and expression. Halloween embraces storytelling filled with magic and wonder, and Jack’s journey becomes a testament to these themes. With Sally by his side, he is not just the Pumpkin King who frightens; he embodies the complexity of the spooky season. Their story invites viewers to see beyond the surface and to embrace the layered narratives that make Halloween rich.
In redefining Halloween through love and connection, “The Nightmare Before Christmas” reveals that what makes the holiday special is found not just in the haunting imagery, but also in the bonds we share. Jack and Sally’s journey enriches the atmosphere of Halloween Town, echoing the true spirit of Halloween — a celebration that welcomes both the eerie and the enchanting. Thus, the film stands firmly as a Halloween movie, encapsulating the essence of fear transformed into love.