The opinions expressed in The Lawrentian are those of the students, faculty and community members who wrote them. The Lawrentian does not endorse any opinions piece except for the staff editorial, which represents a majority of the editorial board. The Lawrentian welcomes everyone to submit their own opinions. For the full editorial policy and parameters for submitting articles, please refer to the About section.
C.S. Lewis’s “The Chronicles of Narnia” holds a special place in my heart as one of my all-time favorite series. It’s one of those treasures from childhood that evokes a deep sense of happiness and nostalgia. Even now, I find it difficult to articulate exactly what captivates me about the series. Perhaps it’s the enchanting landscapes that transport me to otherworldly realms, the unforgettable characters such as Aslan, Mr. Tumnus, Mr. and Mrs. Beaver, Trumpkin and Reepicheep, or maybe it’s the sheer escapism that allows me to lose myself in a world filled with magic and adventure. Each element weaves together to create a tapestry of wonder that continues to draw me back time and again. It was one of the first chapter books I tackled on my own; a milestone in my childhood that solidified my love for literature. I’ll admit that I first encountered “The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe” through its cinematic adaptation, despite my mother’s steadfast rule that one must always read the book before indulging in its movie counterpart — an edict likely rooted in her profession as a high school English teacher. The film captivated my imagination and left me eager to dive into the pages of the book, which I eventually did.
When “Prince Caspian” was released, my excitement soared. I thought Ben Barnes brought Prince Caspian to life with incredible charm and depth, even if the romantic subplot involving him and Susan deviated from the original narrative. Despite these alterations, the film still captured the enchanting essence of Lewis’s world. I prefer not to dwell on “The Voyage of the Dawn Treader,” as that installment sadly faltered in its execution, and I can understand why the series did not continue in its wake. The first two films transported me to a realm where magic thrived and adventure awaited at every turn. They felt surprisingly mature, even though the protagonists were children, which added to their allure. I found myself utterly captivated, watching them repeatedly, drawn into the rich tapestry of Narnia with each viewing.
Before people judge, let me clarify: I recognize that both the books and their adaptations are imbued with biblical themes and religious undertones. I was too young to even notice or understand. However, my appreciation for “Narnia” isn’t born from a belief in those themes or the narratives of faith itself — rather, it stems from the powerful escape it provides. In “Narnia,” I admired Peter’s courage as he faced insurmountable odds, Susan’s cleverness in navigating challenges, Edmund’s compelling redemption arc and Lucy’s unwavering kindness. Each character embodied qualities I aspired to emulate, and their adventures provided me with a sanctuary where imagination thrived and endless possibilities beckoned.
I’ve recently learned that Greta Gerwig — known for her thoughtful direction in films such as “Lady Bird” (2017), “Little Women” (2019) and “Barbie” (2023) — is set to take on the daunting task of remaking “The Chronicles of Narnia” as well as potential sequels. While I acknowledge Gerwig’s notable contributions to cinema, I find myself grappling with mixed emotions about this latest remake announcement.
Remakes can sometimes breathe new life into a beloved story, but more often than not, they struggle to capture the essence of the original. It’s a delicate balance; many adaptations veer too far from their source material, resulting in lackluster outcomes that fail to resonate with audiences. Gerwig’s unique perspective and modern feminist approach have certainly brought a fresh lens to her previous projects. I appreciated her interpretation of “Little Women,” which offered an insightful and contemporary take on a classic narrative. Although I found “Barbie” to be somewhat overrated, I genuinely respect the relevant themes it aimed to explore.
However, the moment I heard about Gerwig’s commitment to remaking “The Chronicles of Narnia,” I felt a wave of frustration wash over me — especially upon discovering rumors suggesting that the adaptation would incorporate a feminist rock-and-roll musical theme. While I am not inherently opposed to the idea of instilling feminist ideologies into this new rendition, considering that such themes were largely absent when C.S. Lewis penned the original series in the 1950s, my primary concern lies in the rock-and-roll musical concept. Moreover, there is palpable anxiety among fans on social media regarding the potential neglect of the rich biblical themes that underpin the “Narnia” saga, though I am not concerned. As I’ve said before, I don’t care much for the biblical themes; I was more focused on the magical creatures and the conflicts within the stories.
Though I may not be a cinematic expert, I felt that the earlier adaptations, particularly “The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe” and “Prince Caspian,” managed to capture the magic of the source material effectively. The visual effects were stunning, the performances were delivered with sincerity and the soundtrack — featuring artists like Alanis Morissette, Imogen Heap and Regina Spektor — beautifully enhanced the enchanting atmosphere of Narnia. In recent years, the film industry has witnessed an overwhelming surge in remakes, leading many to question whether Hollywood has truly run out of original ideas. It often feels as though studios are taking the easy route, opting to reinterpret well-crafted films rather than developing fresh narratives. In doing so, they risk overshadowing the original stories and the profound significance they held for audiences.
Instead of honoring the essence of these classics, many remakes prioritize a contemporary vision that may overlook the emotional and cultural impact the originals had on viewers. I feel compelled to express my thoughts on “The Chronicles of Narnia.” While this viewpoint may not resonate with everyone, I believe it is important to voice it. This literary work holds a special place in my heart, and I don’t want the magic to be diminished when it’s subjected to excessive reinterpretation or commercialization. Greta Gerwig’s overzealous adaptation can potentially strip away the charm and essence of what Narnia captivates, and I don’t want the original integrity to sway. There is such beauty in the original movie, and I don’t want the nostalgia to disappear.